The best tomato sauce you’ve ever tasted. For real. I’m not even exaggerating. Yes!

Love.I bought the tomatoes because they were lovely, but also because I was super-excited at the possibilities for solar tomato sauce. A fascinating idea, I thought, and what a way to have dinner ready in a hurry, just boil some pasta et voila! And then the sky turned grey for the first time in a long, long time and the heat wave broke and the long-range forecast whined rain for the next seven days and I still had the tomatoes, and then Rose at work brought me a bouquet of basil. And then everything was glorious.

Basil from Rose.So, inspired in part by a recipe in this month’s Gourmet and in part by an unsatisfied desire to get to the essence of tomatoes through a batch of solar sauce, I’ve improvised some. And it worked out well. Very well. You will soon find an abundance of little tomatoes at your local market, and this is what you should do with some of them. About 1.5 pounds of them.

(If you’re like me, you’ll want a meatball or two to go along with things. Use this recipe. Add a little bit of spinach and lemon zest. Make the peperonata another time, and eat it cold with crusty bread.)

Make this in a pot you can use on the stove AND in the oven. It works better that way, and is less mess. Also, while I insist you try this with little tomatoes, you don’t have to. I was just lazy and didn’t want to bother with the whole blanching/skinning thing, which I kind of feel obligated to do when the tomatoes are bigger.

Tomato sauce that tastes like tomatoes

  • 1.5 to 2 lbs. fresh cherry tomatoes (or other small tomatoes)
  • 1 bulb of garlic
  • 1/4 cup good olive oil
  • 2 tsp. salt (or to taste)
  • 2 tsp. red chili flakes

Preheat your oven to 400°F.

Halve your little tomatoes, and trim the top off the bulb of garlic. Place your tomatoes in the pot, with the garlic right smack in the middle, and then drizzle the oil over top. Add a teaspoon of the salt, and toss into the oven, where you will bake the whole thing, covered, for thirty minutes.

Lusty.Place the pot on the stove, over medium to medium-low heat. You don’t need the thing to reach a rolling boil. Remove the garlic, and squish the cloves out into the pot. You may want to wait until it’s cool enough to handle – I used a clean dish cloth as a barrier against the heat. The cloves should pop out easily.

At this point, you are going to want to puree the contents of your pot. I recommend using a hand blender, because that’s the best way to keep a bit of texture – you could also use a food mill, a food processor, or a blender. If you’ve removed the mix from the pot to blend, return it to the pot. Taste, add the remainder of the salt and any more if you feel it needs it, and your pepper flakes, and simmer over medium to medium-low heat for another 30 to 40 minutes.

Sauce.Boil a pot of pasta (about one pound uncooked) until cooked to your liking, and then toss the noodles into the sauce pot and make sure every noodley strand is covered in fantastic tomatoey goodness.

Sauced.Serve with chopped fresh basil, a dollop of ricotta, and/or your favourite shaved parmesan cheese. And meatballs. But you knew that.

Mmmm. Mmm!I am completely in love with this tomato sauce, because it tastes exactly like tomatoes, which, especially at this time of year, taste exactly like meaty summer sun, to me. And the garlic adds a nice bit of body, and is not aggressive. The roasting and simmering makes it sweet, so that it plays a supporting role here, heightening the taste of the tomatoes. It’s really very lovely. Go out and make this. Especially if it’s raining – the smell … the smell! The wafting, beautiful aromas of this sauce will make your home smell like all the best parts of your garden, roasting. It’s compliment sauce. As in, everyone who eats this will compliment you on your awesome talent and probably also your incredible good looks, and you will taste it and fall in love with yourself all over again. Sigh!

This kind of reminds me of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, in a good way.

18 thoughts on “The best tomato sauce you’ve ever tasted. For real. I’m not even exaggerating. Yes!

  1. That sounds soooo yummy! I will for sure be trying this one! How do you think the basil would taste cooked in the sauce?


  2. I’ve done this recipe! Thank you so much for sharing! One thing that I really appreciate about it is that you can adapt it with any number of ingredients you’d like to include — you can add mushrooms, peppers, even something random like strawberries, and it will reflect the new ingredients while still being all about the tomato. A really good base!


  3. I’ve ust started making stuff like bread and scones (I’m a 60 year old male) and I wanted to branch out. I tried this and it was so good I’ve done it again and again. The Big Bonus: tomatoes are a superfood with all the antioxidants and lycopene and loads of other vitamins. Something, finally, that tastes great and is a major health benefit? Win win situation!!!


    1. That’s awesome, James – I’m glad you like it. The wonderful thing about this is you can make it all-year round, adapting the recipe slightly to canned tomatoes when tomatoes are not seasonally available. Make sure you use olive oil with the tomatoes – the fat “unlocks” the lycopene in the tomatoes, which makes it more effective in the body.


  4. This sauce is amazing! Especially in the winter when the Tomatoes are not that great, the cherry tomatoes still seem to be sweet. I add cooked pureed sausage and ground beef after I pureed the sauce. And by the way, on a side note, if the sauce is a little watery; I find pasta noodles will hydrate themselves over night in the fridge essentially infusing the taste of the sauce. This makes for really good leftovers! Love the recipe Thanks Again.


  5. Where’s the wine? I pefer a a sauce that’s a bit more complex. While the recipe is good, try adding a 1/2 cup of quality red wine & even a few tablespoons of brandy will add some depth.


  6. OMG, this came out so good. I think I added an onion and some Italian seasoning. Cooked it in my All Clad dutch oven so it went easily from oven to stovetop. My 22 year old son said it was the best sauce he ever had! Thanks so much!


    1. You’re welcome, Linda! I’m glad it went over well 🙂 I’ve been making it this summer with red wine and fresh oregano – everyone’s pretty happy here too!


  7. I used Roma tomatoes so I did blanch and skin which adds about 15 min. to the time for each 2 pounds. The first batch was so good that I canned about 6 quarts. Two pounds of tomatoes makes about 1 1/2 quarts. Everyone loves this sauce.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.